False Positive Breathalyzer Virginia

Learn what causes a false positive breathalyzer result in Virginia, how testing errors can affect DUI charges, and how Invictus Law can help.

When Breath Test Results Raise Serious Questions.

A breathalyzer test can sometimes give an inaccurate reading due to medical conditions, device errors, or problems with how the test was given. An incorrect result may lead to a DUI charge, even when the reading does not reflect your actual blood alcohol level. This guide explains what can cause a false positive breathalyzer result in Virginia and how it may affect your case.

What Causes a False Positive Breathalyzer Result in Virginia?

A false positive breathalyzer result occurs when a breath test shows a higher blood alcohol concentration (BAC) than a person actually has. In Virginia, the legal BAC limit for most drivers is 0.08%. An inaccurate reading may lead to a DUI charge , even when the test does not reflect the driver’s actual BAC.

Several factors may affect the accuracy of a breath test:

  • Mouth alcohol: Alcohol left in the mouth after using mouthwash or breath spray may cause a higher reading.
  • Acid reflux (GERD): Acid reflux can bring stomach contents into the mouth. If those contents contain alcohol, they may affect the breath sample.
  • Diabetes and ketosis: Diabetes, fasting, and certain low-carb diets can cause the body to produce ketones, including acetone. These substances may interfere with some breath testing devices.
  • Lung conditions: Some respiratory conditions may make it difficult to provide a proper breath sample, depending on the device and testing requirements.
  • Environmental factors: Exposure to certain chemical fumes or vapors may interfere with some breath testing devices.

These factors do not automatically mean a breathalyzer result is inaccurate. The type of device used, the circumstances of the test, and other available evidence can help determine whether a reading is reliable.

How Can Breathalyzer Device Errors and Testing Procedures Affect Results?

Breathalyzer accuracy also depends on whether the device is working properly and the test is given correctly. Virginia has rules governing the approval, maintenance, and use of evidentiary breath testing devices. Problems with the instrument or testing process may raise questions about the reliability of a result.

Device Approval, Maintenance, and Calibration

Breath testing devices must meet the standards that apply to their use in Virginia. Maintenance and calibration records can help show whether a device was working as required when a test was given.

Questions to consider include:

  • Was the device approved for evidentiary breath testing in Virginia?
  • Was it properly maintained and calibrated?
  • Were any faults or errors recorded before or during the test?
  • Did the device produce a valid test result?

A problem with a device does not automatically make its result inadmissible. Its significance depends on the nature of the problem and the rules that apply.

Errors in How the Test Was Given

The person administering a breath test must follow the required testing procedures. These procedures help reduce the risk of outside factors affecting the breath sample.

When reviewing a test, relevant questions may include:

  • Did the officer follow the required observation period before testing?
  • Was the breath sample collected according to the required procedures?
  • Were the required breath samples obtained and recorded correctly?
  • Did the officer follow the device’s instructions when an error occurred?

The answers may help determine whether the test was performed correctly and whether its result can be relied upon.

How Can Breath Test Records Help Identify Errors?

The test record and the device’s maintenance history may provide information that is not clear from the BAC reading alone. These records may show when the test took place, whether the device reported an error, and whether the required procedures were followed.

If a breathalyzer result is disputed, reviewing the records tied to that specific test can help identify issues that may affect its reliability.

What Happens After a Breathalyzer Test in Virginia?

An inaccurate breathalyzer result may lead to a DUI charge. If you believe your reading was wrong, understanding the steps that follow can help you identify when the test result may be reviewed or challenged.

  1. The traffic stop and breath test: If an officer suspects that you are driving under the influence, they may ask you to take a preliminary breath test at the roadside. This test may help the officer decide whether to make an arrest, but its result is not used to prove your BAC at trial. After an arrest, you may be asked to take an evidentiary breath test at a police station or jail. The result of that test may be used as evidence in court.
  2. Arrest and first court appearance: If you are charged with DUI, you will receive information about your court date. First-offense misdemeanor DUI cases in Virginia Beach are generally heard in the Virginia Beach General District Court. At your first appearance, the court may address the charge, your legal representation, and the next steps in your case.
  3. Review of the breath test records: Your attorney may request records related to the test, such as the device’s maintenance and calibration records, the test results, and information about how the test was given. These records may help identify errors that could affect the reading’s accuracy.
  4. Pretrial motions: If the evidence raises legal concerns about the breath test, your attorney may ask the court to exclude the result. Whether the court grants that request depends on the nature of the problem and the rules that apply to the test.
  5. Trial or other case resolution: If the case goes to trial, the prosecution must prove the charge. The defense may question the breath test result and present evidence about the device, testing procedures, or other factors that could have affected the reading. Some cases are resolved before trial, depending on the evidence and circumstances.
  6. The court’s decision: If you are convicted, the court will determine the sentence under Virginia law. If the charge is dismissed or you are found not guilty, you will not receive a conviction for that charge. The time needed to resolve a case varies.

The accuracy of a breath test may remain an issue throughout a DUI case. Reviewing the records tied to the specific test can help determine whether there are grounds to question its result.

Talk to a Virginia DUI Attorney About Your Breath Test Result

If a breathalyzer result played a role in your Virginia DUI charge, speaking with an attorney can help you understand how the test was performed and whether its accuracy may be questioned. Invictus Law assists drivers in Virginia Beach, Norfolk, Chesapeake, and the surrounding Hampton Roads area. Contact our team  to discuss your circumstances and learn about the options that may be available in your case.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I Be Charged With DUI if My Breathalyzer Reading Is Below 0.08%?

Yes. In Virginia, a driver may face a DUI charge even if their BAC is below 0.08%. The prosecution may rely on other evidence of impairment, such as driving behavior, the officer’s observations, and field sobriety tests. A reading below 0.08% does not automatically rule out a DUI charge.

Can Acid Reflux or Diabetes Cause a False Positive Breathalyzer Result?

Certain medical conditions may affect a breath test under specific circumstances. Acid reflux can bring alcohol from the stomach into the mouth, while diabetes may cause the body to produce substances that interfere with some testing devices. Whether either condition affected your result depends on the device used and the circumstances of the test.

Can I Challenge a Breathalyzer Result if the Device Was Not Properly Maintained?

Possibly. Maintenance and calibration records may reveal problems with the device at the time of your test. An attorney can review those records and assess whether any errors affect the reliability or admissibility of the result. A maintenance issue does not automatically mean the court will exclude the test.

What Is the Difference Between a Roadside Breath Test and a Breath Test Taken After Arrest?

A roadside preliminary breath test helps an officer decide whether there is reason to make an arrest. Its result cannot be used to prove your BAC at a DUI trial in Virginia. An evidentiary breath test taken after arrest follows different procedures, and its result may be used as evidence in court.

Can a False Positive Breathalyzer Result Affect My Military Career?

A DUI charge may have consequences for a service member beyond the civilian court case. Depending on the circumstances, it may lead to a command review or raise questions about military duties or security clearance eligibility. The outcome of the civilian case does not automatically determine how the military will respond.

Blogs & Articles

Sign up for our newsletter to stay up-to-date!